July 7, 2017

Best Silicone Baking Mat: Reusable Mats for All Your Baking Needs

Best-Silicone-Baking-Mat

More...

I’ve been thinking about being environmentally friendly as of late and how I can incorporate reusable materials in cooking. The first thing that jumps out of my mind is silicone baking mat.

Silicone baking mat has an advantage over disposable wax paper, tin foil and parchment paper primarily because it’s reusable. It doesn’t leak unwanted chemicals to food like wax spray, which may cause some health problems later on and you can use it many times over.

So, make mother earth smile next time you bake by using silicone baking mats.

Introducing Silicone Baking Mats​

So what exactly is silicone baking mat? When you bake something, you need to line the baking sheets to prevent your goodies from sticking to it. Traditionally, you would use parchment paper, wax paper or tin foil. The problem is, you can only use these ones and throw them away, adding to the garbage heap.

For a long time, this is how you line the baking sheets. The thing is, with the environment getting damaged on the daily basis, there is a need to reuse things in order to minimize our impact on the only habitable planet in the solar system. At least in small ways, reusable silicone baking mat does that.

With reusable silicone baking mats, you don’t need to throw your linings after you use them. This recent addition to the lining sheets can withstand temperatures up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit and you can reuse it many times over.

Advantages of Silicone Baking Mats​

The primary advantage of silicone baking mat is the fact that you don’t have to throw it away after using. This translate to savings compared to using disposable linings.

Another advantage is that it works better than other linings when it comes to preventing goodies from sticking to the baking sheets. Those who have used parchment paper and wax paper know that those linings do stick from time to time. Magically, this is not the case for silicone.

Since doesn’t stick at all, cleaning is a breeze. You will love this quality, especially when baking something buttery and sticky. Best of all, silicone baking mats prevent browning of the bottom of the baked goodies.

What to Look for in Silicone Baking Mats​

With so many brands of silicone baking mats, deciding on what’s right for your needs can be tough. You can just imagine the confusion when you’re just about to purchase a set of mats and find out there are literally hundreds of brands out there offering more or less the same thing. To avoid this situation, here are some things to look for:​

  • The right size
  • Food safety
  • Heat resistance
  • Ease of cleaning
  • Money back guarantee

Although silicone mats can resist temperatures up to 500 degrees, this can vary from mat to mat. You have to look for the maximum tolerance of a specific mat to know the highest temperature it can handle.

You will notice in this review that some mats would begin to melt even when subjected to heat that is well below its rating.

​Top Five Silicone Baking Mats

After hours of research and personal use of several mats, I came to the conclusion that these five are the best in the market today. As already mentioned, there are hundreds of silicone mat brands out there and there is just no way for me to be able to review all of them.

This means that this list may not include all that you would consider being the best silicone mats out there. All I’m saying is, these are the best that I have tested.​

Velesco Silicone Baking Mat

Via Amazon.com

The most sought after brand of silicone mats worldwide, the Velesco Silicone Baking Mat is not only durable and functional, it’s also affordable and well designed. It’s easy to maintain and keep clean, this nonstick professionally designed mat is top rated to be non-toxic, food safe and ideal for regular use by the FDA.

The mats come in two half-sheets which measure 11-5/8” x 16-1/2”, which fits the standard half-size baking trays. You can use it for kneading, rolling and baking. It is heat resistant up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit and promises 100% nonstick surface and full refund if you’re not satisfied with it.


Pros

  • Easy to clean
  • Heat resistant up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Fits standard sheets
  • Full money back guarantee
  • 100% nonstick
  • FDA rated to be non-toxic and food safe

Cons

  • Would melt when used in a toaster
  • The mat will discolor when used with heat beyond its rating

AmazonBasics Silicone Baking Mat- 2 Pack

Via Amazon.com

Amazon’s own silicone baking mats offer two nonstick mats that are heat resistant up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit. This food-grade and durable silicone mat can be reused over and over and allows easy food removal.

You can use it with any oven except direct-fire ovens. The mat transfers heat easily from the oven to the food resulting in a consistent result. When you’re done using it, this mat is so easy to clean and dishwasher safe.


Pros

  • Oven-safe
  • Heat resistant up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe
  • Can be used with all kinds of oven except direct-fire ovens

Cons

  • Tends to transfer rubber taste to food
  • Non-stick does not last long
  • Mats can melt after several uses

Artisan Silicone Baking Mat

Via Amazon.com

For a durable baking mat that you can be sure to use over and over, the Artisan Silicone Baking Mat will not disappoint. This is made from strong and pliable woven fiberglass inside and it is encased with nonstick silicone in the outside. This mat comes in two 11” x 16.5” baking mats, perfect for standard baking sheets.

You don’t have to worry about cleaning because it’s dishwasher safe or you can just wipe with a soft cloth. Made from BPA-free and food-grade silicone, you don’t have to worry about toxic ingredients getting into your food.

This mat is highly versatile, you can use it for kneading, freezing and roasting.


Pros

  • Food-grade and BPA-free silicone materials
  • Heat resistant up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Easy to cleaning
  • FDA approved

Cons

  • May still stick with sticky recipes
  • After several uses, mats begin to smoke at 350 degrees
  • Mats tend to get damaged easily

KITZINI Silicone Baking Mat Set (2) Half Sheets

Via Amazon.com

If you want to avoid adding extra calories from oil or butter spray to your food, the KITZINI Silicone Baking Mat Set (2) Half Sheets is for you. This nonstick silicone baking mat turns baking sheets into nonstick surfaces in an instant, you can forget about using parchment even again.

This silicone mat is FDA-certified to be food safe and it can withstand heat up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. It is microwave safe and you can be sure of even heat distribution when baking. If you’re not satisfied with the product, the company offers 100% money back guarantee.


Pros

  • Heat resistant up to 400 degrees Fahrenheit
  • Offers 100% money back guarantee
  • FDA-approved 100% food grade
  • Comes with a free e-book recipe
  • Microwave safe

Cons

  • Stains from food grease are difficult to clean
  • Color tends to transfer to your food
  • The silicone edges will split apart over repeated use

Jollylife 2 Ct Silicone Baking Mat

Via Amazon.com

Made from 100 food grade silicone, you can be sure that the Jollylife 2 Ct Silicone Baking Mat does not contain any trace of BPA. It is heat resistant up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit, this set of two mats fits into a standard size baking sheet.

Unique of all the mats reviewed, this mat is made with pyramid design which keeps the food at elevated position as it cooks. This unique design is intended to prevent the food from browning and it also eliminates any excess grease that the food may have.

The result is a consistently cooked food that is crispier and without any browned portions. You might need a toothbrush to clean this mat especially if food gets in between the pyramids.


Pros

  • Unique pyramid design prevents food from burning
  • Made from 100% food grade silicone
  • Guaranteed BPA-free
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Microwave safe

Cons

  • Gives off that bad plastic smell when temperature exceeds 350 degrees Fahrenheit
  • A bit difficult to clean
  • Food gets uncooked from time to time

​Final Thoughts

Of all the silicone baking mats I’ve reviewed here, the Velesco Silicone Baking Mat is the clear winner. It is the only one that constantly delivers what it promises except when used beyond its ratings.​

All the other mats here showed some problems even when the heat is below its ratings. And while I wanted to go environmentally friendly, the smell of burning plastic of the color transferring to the food kind of defeats the purpose. That is a bit disappointing and a minus to all the mats reviewed.

The pyramid design of the Jollylife 2 Ct Silicone Baking Mat is unique but it also defeats its own purpose because there are times when I got uncooked food in it. I have used the same recipes for this review and it's only the mat design that differs so it must be the culprit.

The good thing with these mats is that it offers 100% money back guarantee and if you're not satisfied or if the mats don't meet its claims, you can go ahead and return it to the manufacturer.

The silicone mat is a new addition to the linings that you can use for baking. And while customer reviews like this abound, this is nevertheless new and still needs to be thoroughly tested. Use it with caution and buy only products with good customer reviews.

How about you? What's your experience with silicone mats? Did the baking go well? Share your experience in the comment section below.​

    Claire J. Ruiz

    I'm Claire, and my passion is cooking. I believe that food is what actually unites people and the dining table is where we set aside our differences. When we eat we become vulnerable because enjoying food requires a different level of trust and surrender to the person preparing your food. Sharing and enjoying food is one of the most intimate experiences in life.​

    Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

    Leave a Reply: